Part 2 Of Passive Control & Sexual Politics
For women, it is my contention that physical violence is not the first option in their repertoire. This is not to suggest that women are not prone to physically violent, I’ve witnessed enough women beating their children in the street to suggest otherwise. Also I’ve seen and known of women beating each other and men in public and private, so the earlier part of this paper covers some of this behaviour; it is my contention here is that women tend to prefer other more subtle forms of control.
The easiest to recognise form of female controlling behaviour is that of the ‘Vaginal Wrench’ – the use of sex or the withholding of the same to gain control or favours of some kind. This of course may run in companion with ‘the Withholding Penis’, where a man’s part in this is to go along with the prevailing notion that sex is scarce and must be paid for in some way. Women are culturally trained that ‘boys want only one thing’, which can reinforce for women the notion that they have control of sex and its expression in relationships. It is important to remember that men can control sex as much they can control other loving behaviours, however, we can understand this best if we use the gender terms used here interchangeably.
Controlling sex has been a major issue for feminism, initially the advances that contraception gave women to be equal players in the game of ‘free sex’ seemed inviting, and then, as it dawned that these new ideas didn’t fully redress the power imbalances nor alter the core issues – some returned to older styles of thinking. Such behaviours may have been packaged as ‘owning our bodies’ or the ‘right to orgasm’, but these to me are old ideas painted as new, women have always controlled when sex took place, how it took place and how often. Anything else is called rape.
Though to build a philosophy based upon the meanness of spirit of the controlling few is what some women appear to have done. ‘It is our burden to bear men the pleasure of sex; therefore they must pay for their pleasures’ seems to be suggested by some controlling women. Though the gain may not be sexually pleasurable, the gain in economic or political terms is immense as victims demand or exact compensation.
When controlling sex, the demand is that others know the difference between a cuddle and a prelude to sex without ‘the controller’ having to articulate their own needs. This is a perennial complaint from some male clients – and indeed colleagues – I meet, that “women will not articulate their needs”. What happens instead is a mummers play of trying to get something right without quite knowing what the something is.
Likewise from women: “I have to ask for him to love me, his work/hobbies, seem more important…he doesn’t talk to me…’
I recognise here immediately a game in action; if true intimacy is taking place then ‘anything and everything’ can and will be articulated. True intimacy is not like pop songs; depth in relationship stems from loving the other, as they are, not how we would want them to be. It honours and respects difference. Intimacy dispels fear; control creates fears, insincerity and ‘Games’.
Nagging – Controlling the Water-Torture Way
The next easiest control behaviour to spot is nagging; ‘the nag’ holds a comfort spot in my understanding of control. Comfortable, as we all know that the nag has only our interests at heart, knows what is best, the cosy comfortable nag, the aunt, the uncle, the killing with kindness of a grandparent.
Supposedly ‘the nag’ superficially appears is upfront about what they want, the changes needed to make them happy. But are they? ‘The nag’ though delivers two messages, the up front message: ‘do this’ or ‘do that’, ‘you know you must do the right thing’. However, underlying this is the more important message: ‘you are not right’; ‘not OK’. This hidden message is the more important message: ‘your not rightness means that you cannot and do not make me happy’ As this is a controlling power game played to the third degree: you are not right. If the recipient does not wake up to the underlying message, years of misery can occur. True happiness lies within us; it is not dependent upon others. We all must learn to accept responsibility for our controlling behaviour, and must come to appreciate that others cannot make us happy.
Controlling behaviour always has messages of: ‘you must work harder to make me happy’. Otherwise there would be no need to control. We learn such behaviours as these initially from ‘Mum’ or from others fulfilling a parenting role. Of course parents must teach us what is right and wrong; however, they need to do this without giving meanings to children that they are wrong or bad, this is the real trick to good parenting; one which unfortunately few of us manage.
Initially, nagging and ‘you are not OK’ messages begin relatively innocuously, changing from “I prefer you in….” to eventually “you (they) never know what to buy/wear.” I use this general example only to demonstrate the shift from helping behaviour into Controlling behaviour; the recipient is not right, the speaker holds the power of authority in deciding the truth of situations. Here the first statement is about the speaker, the second tells you how lacking in ‘rightness’ the other is.
My specific example of this; one morning I woke feeling fed up, feeling down, I was dealing with a lot of stressful situations at the time. I breakfasted, showered and went off to meet a friend. We spoke, I told of feeling of my feeling fed up etc. at the end they said “Go home, shave, change” I left feeling that this exchange somehow wasn’t right. It wasn’t until much later that I made the connection, I was being told that it wasn’t O.K. for me to look or be fed up around them, I must shave, be perfect (right) for them, though she was supposed to be a friend, I could only be O.K. on their terms. It would have been different if, maybe, I’d been invited to take some time, relax etc. I feel this would have been more about me, rather than their having to ‘view my down.’
Such situations as these can be so seductively subtle. The nag and the ‘vaginal wrencher’ have nothing on these controllers; their art is in having their needs met without actually asking for them – specifically. And therein lies their terrifying beauty, by not being specific; their victims cannot ever meet their controllers needs. The controlling game will continue on forever until these deadly practices get broken. Just note how subtle this victim-like power is, for we are placed in a position where our ‘inarticulacy’ stems from not so much learning to articulate our own needs, but from having learned to meet and articulate the needs of another.
Controlling behaviour is exactly what it is, whether violence, nagging, vaginal wrenching or holding the view that others are somehow ‘not right.’ All these are designed to bring others under control.
The only way to end controlling behaviour is by the conquest of real intimacy, an acceptance of fear and an acceptance of others as they are, not as we want them to be.
Postscript: There’s a whole world of difference for me between those of us attempting to understand, ‘the what is’ or ‘what happens around us’ and
those who fill the void or apparent lack of meaning by controlling others so as to cling by their fingernails to their limited understanding of their world.
I feel I recognise myself wholly in the first and glimpse my reflection in the
second; when there was precious little love around me, I tried to hang on to what I could. Luckily, the little love there was, stopped my pursuit to teach me I needed to love me first.
Neil Benbow
(c)neilbenbow2026
Leave a Reply