A Flight from Empathy? (part 1)
Preamble: This essay is written for those – such as myself – who have survived ‘controlling relationships’ and for those still in such relationships.
I write regarding the behaviour of men and women who ‘control’ or attempt to control others.
Such ‘controlling personalities’ are seen to manipulate others behaviour for their own gratification, but because their manipulation is coercive and covert, their needs are (often purposely and intentionally) never clearly articulated.
The account is written for people who have found themselves as recipients or targets of controlling behaviour, for those who have ‘walked away’, and for those such as myself – survivors of such relationships who wish to better understand these behaviours.
My focus is on how individuals attempt to control others, behaviour within groups, in one to one relationships and families. The behaviours discussed here are used by both men and women; however, violence as a control –which is used more often by men – forms the basis for the first part of my essay.
Dynamics of Control & the Socialisation to Compliance
The main issue to remember about controlling people is that their behaviour is always interpreted as ‘somebody else’s’ problem. Nobody else is seen to really exist in ‘their universe’ except them. In its extreme form, theirs is a narcissistic way of being; they hold a complete lack of empathy. If they were to be person-sensitive, to understand or fully understood another’s ‘way of being in the world’ and to appreciate that others existed independently to themselves, they could not exercise control in the manner they do.
Simply, they do receive empathy but rather use it to further their own goals through manipulative behaviour. For example, any information given to ‘a controller’ tends to rebound, ‘Ah, but you said…’ as they remind us that they are only doing what we have indirectly requested from them in the first place.
If you are familiar with the feeling of ‘walking on eggshells’ around somebody or being scared to speak in case you are misperceived or yet again enrage a certain somebody or draw further flak from them, well, then you know what I mean by this. In this context, all your attempts to understand, aid or empathise are used to ‘the controllers ends’, not as you initially expected nor intend to build rapport, personal understanding or to ease relational tension.
For instance, we see in the extract below provided by a fellow teacher, how a narcissistic self-orientated controlling personality may come to perceive ‘difference’ as an affront:
“I remember a tutorial colleague who I was at one time on good terms with, but who consistently saw my need to explore a situation and to work openly with a group as a refusal to follow her directions and wishes. She was director of the course I taught upon, and she worked from a plan of action which guided her through her tuition; I conversely, would walk in with broad intentions but tailor my teaching to what was arising ‘now’ in the group field. I did not try to hide my intentions from her, but try as I might to explain my rationale, she still felt excluded and accused me of consistently failing to follow her directions and of keeping her out.
At root, what started out as a stylistic difference, developed into a scenario where she kept accumulating evidence to justify her position that I was untrustworthy and slippery and that she was being consistently undermined as the course leader; whatever I did, however I accounted for my actions was twisted around to justify her entrenched position.
For instance, although I did not work to the letter to implement the brief she insisted I follow, I still achieved a favourable outcome and received very positive student reports which achieved the end she had in mind, but, because she couldn’t see how I could achieve success beyond her terms of reference, I was further accused of subverting students opinions and of turning them against her.
As time went on she began to treat it as self-evident that I was out to embarrass her. Eventually I had to leave because nothing short of compliance or open warfare would have changed the situation”.
We see above how a controller’s behaviour is like that of a drug pusher, they give only a little bit of the drug at the beginning, then slowly over time increase the dosage.
The idea of a drug-pusher works well here, for such behaviours is directed to make another person – this time ‘you’ – dependent on them.
At root all actions by ‘the controller’ are designed to strip away the independence of the person they wish to control. What they cannot understand they fear, what they fear they seek to control, and what they fail to control becomes the enemy. What makes this even more perverse is that often as not ‘the controllers’ behaviour and motives remain out of their conscious awareness.
The drug analogy works for me here because it takes the intended victim – ‘the controller’ – into an altered state of consciousness which disconnects them from their friends, family, and the rest of the world.
Such alienation and isolation as this is a perfect breeding ground for paranoia and projection. Also, unless the controlled person was raised within a manipulative environment, then overt forms of control will in turn threaten and repel them and be treated competitively.
I wish to underscore here, that on some level ‘the controller’ may recognise their behaviour is unacceptable, and hence that they need to seduce slowly but surely over time their victim into victim-hood and isolation.
There is only room for one ‘parent’ in their world, and as they are it, others need to be enrolled as ‘children’! This slow seduction often entraps their victim into accepting that their worldview as the correct way of doing things. People – victims of ‘controllers’ – after leaving such relationships will be puzzled how they became involved in such destructive relationships in the first place. ‘How could I have let myself become so ensnared?’ they will often ask. What they fail to realise is that their own empathy for others – and indeed ‘the controller’ – has been used against them and they have been subjected to a non-empathetic one-way relationship.
Another way of looking at this is that it is to compare it to brutal army/navy training where the person is shocked by the demands made upon them i.e. that they must fundamentally change their hair, clothes, behaviour; the subtext is clearly one of ‘if you want to belong and to be with OK with me this is how you must be’.
In the worst scenario a person complies, loses a sense of self and comes to accept a new regime and way of being entirely different from how they have ever been before.
A seductive element of this, as with forces training, is that certainties abound. For those who need certainties or ‘right ways of being’ these relationships initially offer the more needy ‘victims’ a role with a certain kind of security.
Having been in the Royal Navy I look back with fascination to the beliefs that I held unquestioningly – and still hear expressed by my friends who are still in the Navy. These beliefs offer certainties about the world and their (and once mine) place within it.
To not hold the views held as certainties by the Navy – as in other controlling relationships – results in sanctions…What this does in relationships is to place all knowledge, all authority and information with ‘the controller’, this reduces further still the independence of the person being controlled.
Upon Self-Victimisation & Political Cowardice
Cowardice and collusion enter the picture here: other people will often know what ‘the controller’ is like, their family and friends and colleagues will know what they are like, but all may be too scared of the consequences if they go against whatever ‘the controller’ wants.
The consequences of staying in this situation may lead to loss of self-esteem with silent compliance, increasing frustration and an outburst of violence, absenteeism and stress reactions, sulking, communication by notes, until eventually the recipient learns to give up or walk away.
Giving up is akin to: ‘anything for a quiet life’; ‘anything to keep them happy.’ This cowardice is two-edged; the first edge concerns dealing with ‘the controller’ and not wanting to face the consequences of saying no. The second – and one in which we all play a part as ‘survivors’ or as passive bystanders – is our own not wanting to face up to understanding that we have let somebody else have control over our lives. To face ourselves in this situation and to aid our friends, we need to understand that we have allowed another’s needs and wishes precedence over our own.
To find autonomy again can be a long hard road, and to proffer trust again to others may not come easy. Esteem can become so low that they, the victim, may have forgotten what their own needs, wants and wishes are, for anything else outside of that narrow relationship promises ‘a new unknown’ and a potentially scary life. My aim here is not to disparage those who have entered into or endured these controlling relationships, but rather to suggest that ‘cowardice’ may be the one of the last qualities they have to accept about themselves.
Indeed, a sort of inverse cowardice that masquerades as bravery might represent what keeps them in the abusive relational loop. For instance, they may have suffered long and continuing violence, extreme hardships, broken bones, and yet see themselves as brave – because for them to leave the relationship they are in would be a cowardly act!
My point here is that endurance of these behaviours stems not from bravery but from misplaced loyalty that a controller promotes for his or her own needs.
My experience of this behaviour suggests that controllers may not even recognise their own expression of violence for what it is; their victims may also be seduced into not recognising this also.
After a time violence becomes casual; this increases in the victim a sense of unreality about their situation and allows ‘the controller’ to escalate their violence… or even more sadly, that the victim is seen – or yet perceives themselves as having a part in inviting such violence.
To walk away from controlling behaviour is bravery of the highest kind; to walk into the unknown from the known is true courage. For those of us as onlookers, as friends who wish to help break these patterns, this recognition must be made paramount: the controller may accuse their victim of being a coward by; ‘leaving before things are sorted…’.
The victim is leaving what they have been seduced into knowing as ‘right ways to be’; ways of being which in perverse way offered a sense of security.
Un-Congesting the Pattern & Moving Towards Health
Our role as people with honour, whether in helping roles or as humane human beings is to provide a helping recognition that the major problem within the relationship lies with the controller and that they continue their behaviours because it works for them. I find it best to remind would be survivors of controlling people, not to confront, contradict or conflict. The only way is to ‘walk away’.
Any confrontation forces ‘the controller’ further into being right, into defending his or her position, into being ‘misunderstood’, and anybody who would contradict is seen as misguided or stupid. Contradiction serves only as further vindication; to walk away is the only answer.
Conflict is what controllers ‘do’ best; to enter the arena is to enter the controller’s area of expertise. Here they hold the skill-set; they have the practice in manipulation and fluency in ‘stickiness’.
Stickiness is the feeling generated around these behaviours, like trudging through mud, every sentence has a rebuttal that not quite resolves, another ‘yes but’ to refute, but there is never an acceptable answer, and it is this never-ending entanglement which eventually saps a victims last vestige of energy. The controller does not want clarity nor seeks understanding, knowing this, what are we to do other than walk way?
From my experience of working with clients who have left such relationships, when they walk away, they can be left with ‘it all went wrong’, ‘I did my best but if only I had done more’, all of which is a hangover from their controlling training.
After all, the controller wants them to feel like it was their fault, wants them to feel like they got it wrong, they could have done more, if only they hadn’t been so stupid.
This game can go on for years, after separation, after divorce, even long after their controller has found a new victim. Support for survivors can be lengthy; self esteem once stripped in this way can take time to rebuild.
Counsellors may be the only support that a survivor has; ‘the controller’ will have worked at destroying all other supports to reinforce their own control.
Children can be drawn into the game, as can friends and family.
Remind survivors not to expect too much support from the controller’s friends and family because they will be reminded of their own cowardice by the courage taken in walking away. They may pass the odd message like: ‘we knew what they were like all along.’
However, they rarely engage in a lengthy conversation or lengthy correspondence, because this would exacerbate their relationship with ‘the controller’ and if the controller were to discover a continuing relationship this would invite repercussions for them. Controllers cut off potential support networks for fear they may expose them for what they are.
Having left ‘a controller’ feelings of self-stupidity may often remain.
Again, typical reactions may be: ‘How come I didn’t know? Or ‘If only others had told me how they felt’.
All of these plus others add to a damaging sense of self-stupidity.
However, it is vitally important to remind those who have managed to get away to remember that ‘the controller’s’ existence and happiness were the driving issues within the relationship, nothing more was important.
Any information that did not fit what they wanted would be chopped off; for example, if somebody said something disparaging about the controller’s behaviour, like as not it was interpreted as ‘something wrong with the speaker’: ‘malice’, ‘jealousy’ etc. So overtime the controlled person becomes increasingly isolated; as all attention is going towards the controller, there less space for any other information to come in.
A common feature of this is that victims spend a lot of time and energy explaining away ‘the controllers’ actions, somehow making it right in the world for them to stay and the other to behave in that way.
Perhaps saying at parties ‘Oh they didn’t mean it that way’, or if they do not turn up to the party making an excuse for their non-attendance, when in fact they could not attend a social function because ‘the controller’ had banned attendance possibly with the implied threat of violence.
Parties often feature here, as social events which are a source of anxiety for controllers: here’s a venue where others may observe their behaviour and see it for what it is.
Also, social events break down the isolation they have erected around their victim. It is important to remember that this explaining away of behaviour continues for years afterwards.
Culturally, we are ‘not supposed to say nasty things about people’, but at the last we must speak our truth in order to break free of unhealthy compliance.
But to tell ‘the truth’ is often embarrassing.
To say as now what was previously unsaid, as a client once did to me: “he locked me in the bathroom, threatened to beat me if I came out and for years afterwards my sister thought that I had been ill on her 30th birthday party”. In this instance, it was only when she finally told her sister the truth she was able to fully recognise and comprehend how she had been controlled in that relationship – such was her self-blinding.
Hopefully, when survivors leave the relationship, ‘the controller’ will not be a controller in their next relationship. Vitally for survivors, it is important that the past, present and future behaviour of a controller is seen to have nothing to do with neither them nor anybody else – but solely ‘the controller’.
It is important for us to remember ‘we are not the problem’ in relationships where others are controlling, but that we rather demonstrate behaviour, behaviour that it is possible to divorce ourselves from in order to re-conquest our emotional health. Vitally for us, we need to remember that when others or ourselves have become addicted to a drug or been subject to a brutal training regime, it is hard to kick the habit.
Victims must be encouraged to surrender external control, to find ways of self-support beyond habits of external control.
To walk away, to be healthy, they will need to divorce themselves emotionally from the controlling person and say: ‘that’s who they were with me, how they are with the next person has got nothing to do with me.’ Any effort, any emotion, any time that we spend thinking about them and their actions puts us back into a controlling game.
When we think about them we give them importance again, better to move beyond them. We have to let them go; to talk about them, to gossip or even think about them places us back there. To exact vengeance is to continue the game; let it be enough that we are out of it.
Reluctantly, I am reminded that men, with their strength advantage are primarily given to exhibit physical violence and intimidation, and that a male frustrated by a more mentally agile vocal female partner may use their physical prowess to intimidate their partner.
This more overt system of control will now be contrasted with a more covert one, as demonstrated in the arena of sexual politics described below.
part 2 to follow
Neil Benbow
(c)neilbenbow
Leave a Reply